Skip to main content
Disputes arise in many landlord-tenant relationships. How they’re handled determines whether conflicts resolve quickly or escalate to costly legal battles. Understanding resolution options helps both parties address issues effectively.

​
Common Disputes

Disagreements over deductions, return timing, or itemization. Most common dispute type. Often resolved in small claims court.
Tenant claims landlord isn’t maintaining property. Landlord claims conditions don’t require action. May involve code enforcement.
Disputes over whether violations occurred, severity, or proper notice. Includes noise complaints, unauthorized occupants, pet violations.
Disagreements over amounts owed, late fees, or payment application. May involve claims of improper charges.
Tenant claims improper entry or harassment. Landlord claims legitimate access needs. Often escalates relationship problems.
Disputes over property condition, cleaning standards, or damage responsibility at tenancy end.

​
Resolution Options

Best for: Minor issues, misunderstandings, ongoing relationshipsPut concerns in writing. Focus on specific issues and desired resolution. Keep copies of all communication.Often resolves disputes before escalation. Creates documentation if issues continue.
Best for: Moderate disputes, parties willing to compromiseNeutral third party helps facilitate agreement. Non-binding unless parties sign settlement. Often free or low-cost through community programs.Preserves relationships better than litigation. Faster and cheaper than court.
Best for: Code violations, habitability issuesLocal housing or code enforcement investigates complaints. Can order landlord to make repairs. May impose fines for violations.Creates official record. Does not award damages to tenant.
Best for: Monetary disputes under state limit (typically 5,000−5,000-15,000)Simplified court process. No attorney required. Filing fees typically 30−30-100. Decisions usually within weeks.Judge decides based on evidence. Judgment is legally enforceable.
Best for: Complex disputes, amounts exceeding small claims limitsFormal legal process. Attorney usually necessary. Can take months or years. Higher costs but more thorough process.May be required for eviction defense, discrimination claims, or large damage claims.

​
Before Escalating

1

Document everything

Photos, written communications, receipts, dates, and witnesses. Documentation often determines outcomes.
2

Review the lease

Understand what both parties agreed to. Many disputes stem from different interpretations of lease terms.
3

Know the law

State and local laws may override lease terms. Research applicable requirements before taking positions.
4

Communicate in writing

Put concerns and requests in writing. Keep copies. Creates record if dispute escalates.
5

Attempt resolution

Many disputes resolve through direct communication. Courts look favorably on parties who tried to resolve issues first.

​
Demand Letters

A formal written demand often resolves disputes or is required before legal action. Effective demand letters include:
  • Specific facts (dates, amounts, incidents)
  • Applicable law or lease provisions violated
  • Specific remedy requested
  • Deadline for response
  • Consequences if not resolved
Many states require demand letters before small claims filing, especially for security deposit disputes. Check local requirements.

​
Small Claims Court Process

Complete court forms identifying parties, amount claimed, and basis for claim. Pay filing fee. Court schedules hearing date.
Defendant must be formally notified of lawsuit. Usually by mail, process server, or sheriff. Proof of service required.
Organize evidence: lease, photos, receipts, communications, move-in/move-out documentation. Prepare brief summary of facts.
Both parties present their case to judge. Bring all documentation and witnesses. Be concise and factual.
Judge issues decision, often same day. Winner may be awarded damages, costs, and statutory penalties where applicable.
Winning doesn’t guarantee payment. May need to garnish wages, levy bank accounts, or place liens. Additional court process may be required.
Tenants should consult attorneys for:
  • Eviction defense
  • Discrimination claims
  • Serious habitability issues
  • Retaliation claims
  • Disputes involving significant money
Landlords should consult attorneys for:
  • Before filing eviction
  • Tenant counterclaims
  • Fair housing complaints
  • Complex lease disputes
  • Disputes involving significant money
Many areas have free legal resources:
  • Tenants: Legal aid societies, tenant rights organizations, law school clinics
  • Landlords: Local landlord associations, real estate attorney consultations
  • Both: Court self-help centers, mediation programs

​
Preventing Disputes

Clear communication about expectations, rules, and concerns prevents many conflicts. Written documentation of agreements, condition, and communications provides clarity. Prompt responses to maintenance requests and concerns prevent escalation. Following proper procedures for notices, entry, and deposits avoids technical violations. Knowing the law helps both parties understand rights and obligations.

Back to Landlord-Tenant Overview

Overview of landlord-tenant law

Find Real Estate Attorneys

Research attorneys experienced in landlord-tenant disputes