How Commission Works
Commission basics
Commission basics
Real estate commission is a fee paid for agent services, typically calculated as a percentage of the property sale price.Key points:
- Paid at closing from sale proceeds
- No sale means no commission
- Amount is negotiable
- Split between multiple parties
Who pays commission
Who pays commission
Traditional model: Seller pays total commission out of sale proceeds at closing.Buyer-paid commission: In some markets or situations, buyers may compensate their own agent directly through buyer-broker agreement.Recent changes: Real estate commission practices have evolved. The traditional model where sellers pay both agents’ commissions is no longer universal. Buyers should discuss commission arrangements with their agent upfront.
Commission split
Commission split
Total commission is divided:
- Seller pays total commission (traditional model)
- Split between brokerages: Listing brokerage and buyer’s brokerage each receive a portion
- Split between broker and agent: Each brokerage splits its portion with the individual agent
Example:
- $400,000 sale price
- 5% total commission = $20,000
- Split: $10,000 to listing side, $10,000 to buyer’s side
- Each brokerage keeps portion and pays agent remainder based on their agreement
Typical Commission Rates
Market variations
Market variations
Commission rates vary significantly by location and market conditions. There is no standard or typical rate.Rates are always negotiable between seller and listing agent.
Factors affecting commission
Factors affecting commission
Commission may be influenced by:
- Local market customs
- Property price (higher-priced homes may have lower percentage)
- Property condition and marketability
- Services provided
- Competition among agents
- Market conditions (hot vs slow market)
- Complexity of transaction
Luxury properties
Luxury properties
High-value properties often have lower commission percentages but higher dollar amounts.A $2 million property might have a lower percentage rate than a $300,000 property, but still results in substantial compensation.
Alternative Fee Structures
Flat fee
Flat fee
Fixed dollar amount regardless of sale price.When used:
- Discount brokerages
- Limited service models
- Very high-value properties
Tiered commission
Tiered commission
Different rates at different price points.Example: Higher percentage on first $500,000, lower percentage above that amount.More common with luxury properties.
Hourly or retainer
Hourly or retainer
Some brokerages charge by the hour or monthly retainer instead of commission.Rare in residential real estate. More common with:
- Real estate consultants
- Specific advisory services
- Commercial real estate in some cases
Discount brokerages
Discount brokerages
Reduced commission in exchange for limited services:May include:
- MLS listing only
- Limited marketing
- No showings assistance
- Minimal negotiation support
What Commission Covers
Marketing expenses
Marketing expenses
Professional marketing costs agents incur:
- Professional photography
- Virtual tours and video
- Staging consultation
- Print marketing materials
- Online advertising
- Open house expenses
- Signage and lockboxes
Time and expertise
Time and expertise
Agent time investment:
- Property showings (often evenings and weekends)
- Market research and analysis
- Negotiation time
- Transaction coordination
- Problem-solving
- Communication and updates
- Paperwork and documentation
Business overhead
Business overhead
Agent business expenses:
- MLS and association dues
- Licensing and continuing education
- Errors and omissions insurance
- Office and administrative costs
- Technology and software
- Transportation
Broker split
Broker split
Agents don’t keep full commission:
- Broker receives portion for supervision, office, insurance
- New agents may split 50/50 with broker
- Experienced agents may keep 70-90%
- Some pay flat fees instead of percentage to broker
Negotiating Commission
Commission is negotiable
Commission is negotiable
Sellers can negotiate commission with listing agent:
- No standard or fixed rate
- Discuss rate before signing listing agreement
- Consider value provided, not just cost
- Compare offerings from multiple agents
What to consider
What to consider
When evaluating commission:
- Marketing plan quality
- Agent experience and track record
- Services included
- Agent’s market share and reach
- Comparable sales data
- Your property’s marketability
Negotiation timing
Negotiation timing
Commission negotiation happens:
- During listing presentation
- Before signing listing agreement
- As part of total service discussion
Buyer agent compensation
Buyer agent compensation
Buyers should discuss compensation with their agent:
- How will agent be compensated
- Amount expected
- If seller doesn’t offer to pay, who pays
- Impact on offer strategy
Additional Costs
For sellers
For sellers
Costs beyond agent commission:
- Closing costs (title insurance, recording fees, etc.)
- Property repairs or improvements
- Staging costs
- Home warranty for buyer
- Prorated property taxes
- HOA fees and assessments
- Moving expenses
For buyers
For buyers
Costs beyond agent commission (if applicable):
- Down payment and closing costs
- Inspection fees
- Appraisal fee
- Lender fees
- Title insurance
- Homeowners insurance
- Moving expenses
Transaction coordinator fees
Transaction coordinator fees
Some agents charge separate fees for:
- Transaction coordination
- Administrative services
- Document preparation
Getting Value
Full-service value
Full-service value
What full-commission agents typically provide:
- Comprehensive marketing
- Professional photography and materials
- Active showing management
- Skilled negotiation
- Full transaction coordination
- Problem resolution
- Local market expertise
When to consider discount options
When to consider discount options
Situations where limited-service might work:
- Hot market with high demand
- Pristine, highly desirable property
- Seller with time and willingness to handle tasks
- FSBO with MLS listing access needed
- Very straightforward transaction
Questions to ask
Questions to ask
- What services are included in your commission?
- What marketing will you provide?
- How do you handle showings?
- What is your negotiation experience?
- How available are you throughout the process?
- What happens if challenges arise?