Skip to main content
Homeowners insurance premiums vary significantly based on property characteristics, owner factors, and coverage choices. Understanding what drives costs helps homeowners make informed decisions and identify opportunities for savings. Some factors are within your control. Others are fixed characteristics of your property or location.

​
Property Factors

Where your home is located significantly impacts premiums.Higher premiums:
  • Coastal areas (hurricane, flood risk)
  • Tornado-prone regions
  • Wildfire zones
  • High-crime neighborhoods
  • Areas with expensive construction costs
  • Distance from fire station or hydrant
Lower premiums:
  • Low natural disaster risk
  • Low crime areas
  • Close to fire department
  • Fire hydrant within 1,000 feet
Location cannot be changed, but understanding risk factors helps explain premium differences.
Older homes typically cost more to insure.Why older homes cost more:
  • Outdated electrical, plumbing, or heating systems
  • Higher likelihood of claims
  • More expensive repairs due to materials or construction
  • May not meet current building codes
Updating major systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC, roof) can reduce premiums on older homes.
Building materials affect both fire risk and repair costs.Lower premiums:
  • Brick or stone exterior
  • Fire-resistant roofing (metal, tile, slate)
  • Concrete block construction
Higher premiums:
  • Wood frame construction
  • Wood shake or shingle roof
  • Older materials
Roof is one of the most important premium factors.Lower premiums:
  • New roof (under 10 years)
  • Impact-resistant shingles
  • Metal or tile roofing
  • Good condition documented by inspection
Higher premiums:
  • Roof over 15-20 years old
  • Wood shake shingles
  • Visible wear or damage
  • Prior roof claims
New roof can reduce premiums 10-20% or more.
Larger homes and higher replacement costs mean higher premiums.More square footage means more to rebuild. Higher quality finishes cost more to replace.Premium is roughly proportional to dwelling coverage amount.
Pools increase liability risk and premiums.Premium increase: 5-10% or moreMitigation:
  • Fencing with self-latching gate
  • Pool cover
  • Alarm system
  • Diving board removal (highest risk)
Some insurers exclude pool coverage or decline to insure homes with certain pool features.
Trampolines significantly increase injury risk.Some insurers:
  • Charge higher premiums
  • Exclude trampoline injuries from coverage
  • Decline to insure homes with trampolines
Disclose trampolines when applying. Non-disclosure can void coverage.
Certain breeds are associated with higher bite claims.Commonly restricted breeds:
  • Pit bulls and Staffordshire terriers
  • Rottweilers
  • German Shepherds
  • Doberman Pinschers
  • Chows
  • Akitas
  • Wolf hybrids
Some insurers charge more, exclude coverage for dog bites, or decline to insure. Others don’t consider breed at all.Policies vary significantly. Shop around if you have a restricted breed.

​
Owner Factors

Prior claims are strong predictors of future claims.Impact:
  • Recent claims (3-5 years) increase premiums
  • Multiple claims have compounding effect
  • Even claims at previous addresses count
  • Water damage and liability claims weigh heavily
Claims remain on your record (CLUE report) for 5-7 years.Filing small claims may cost more in premium increases than the claim payout. Consider paying small losses out of pocket.
Most states allow insurers to use credit information in pricing.What’s considered:
  • Payment history
  • Outstanding debt
  • Length of credit history
  • New credit inquiries
  • Credit utilization
Not the same as credit score. Insurance scores weight factors differently than lending scores.Impact: Can affect premiums by 20-50% or more.States that prohibit or limit use: California, Maryland, Massachusetts, Hawaii, Michigan (varies by state).
Continuous coverage is viewed favorably.Higher premiums or difficulty getting coverage:
  • Gaps in insurance history
  • Prior policy cancellations
  • Non-renewals by previous insurer
Maintain continuous coverage even if switching carriers.
Who lives in the home affects risk.Owner-occupied: Lowest premiums. Owners maintain property better and are present to prevent losses.Rental property: Higher premiums. Requires landlord policy (not standard homeowners).Vacant: Much higher premiums or specialty coverage required. Empty homes have higher risk of undetected damage, vandalism, and theft.
Your CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) report contains your claims history. Request free copy annually at LexisNexis.com to review for accuracy.

​
Coverage Choices

Higher deductible means lower premium, but more out-of-pocket per claim.Typical options:
DeductiblePremium Impact
$500Highest premium
$1,00010-15% savings
$2,50020-30% savings
$5,00030-40% savings
Choose deductible you can afford to pay if claim occurs. Don’t select high deductible just for savings if you can’t cover it.
Higher limits cost more.Dwelling coverage: Should match rebuilding cost. Don’t underinsure to save premium.Personal property: Default is percentage of dwelling. May need adjustment based on actual belongings.Liability: Increasing from $100,000 - $300,000 is relatively inexpensive. Higher limits recommended for most homeowners.
Replacement cost coverage costs more but pays significantly more at claim time.Premium difference: 10-15% more for replacement costClaim difference: Can be 40-60% more payoutReplacement cost is worth the premium for most homeowners.
Additional coverage options increase premiums.Common endorsements:
  • Scheduled personal property (jewelry, art)
  • Water backup coverage
  • Equipment breakdown
  • Identity theft protection
  • Home business coverage
  • Ordinance or law coverage
Add endorsements based on actual needs.

​
Discounts

Combining home and auto with same insurer typically saves 10-25%.Largest single discount available. Always get bundled quotes when shopping.Also called multi-policy discount.
Devices that reduce risk earn discounts.Common discounts:
  • Monitored burglar alarm: 5-15%
  • Monitored fire alarm: 5-15%
  • Smoke detectors: 2-5%
  • Deadbolt locks: 2-5%
  • Fire extinguishers: 2-5%
  • Water leak detection: 3-5%
  • Smart home devices: Varies
Monitored systems (professionally monitored, not self-monitored) earn larger discounts.
Newer homes have fewer claims and earn discounts.Typical discounts:
  • New construction: 10-20%
  • Discount decreases as home ages
  • Usually expires after 10-15 years
No claims in recent years earns discount.Typical discount: 5-20% for 3-5+ claim-free yearsSome insurers offer claim forgiveness, preventing first claim from affecting premium.
Staying with same insurer may earn discount.Typical discount: 5-10% after 3-5 yearsHowever, loyalty discount may not offset premium creep. Compare rates periodically.
How you pay can save money.
  • Pay in full annually: 5-10% savings
  • Automatic payment: 2-5% savings
  • Paperless billing: 2-5% savings
  • Electronic funds transfer: 1-3% savings
Some insurers offer group discounts.
  • Alumni associations
  • Professional organizations
  • Employer groups
  • Military/veterans
  • Credit unions
Ask about available affinity discounts.
Not all discounts stack, and advertised discounts don’t always result in lowest overall premium. Compare total premium from multiple insurers rather than counting discounts.

​
Ways to Lower Premiums

Premiums vary significantly between insurers for identical coverage. Get at least 3-5 quotes.Shop every 2-3 years even if satisfied. Rates change and new options emerge.
Increasing deductible from $500 to $1,000 can save 10-15%. Going to $2,500 saves 20-30%.Ensure you have savings to cover higher deductible if needed.
Combine home and auto for significant discount. May also bundle umbrella, boat, or other policies.
Install monitored alarm system, deadbolts, and smoke detectors. Discounts often exceed device costs within a few years.
Replace old roof, electrical, plumbing, or HVAC. Notify insurer after updates for potential premium reduction.
In states where credit is used, better credit means lower premiums. Pay bills on time, reduce debt, correct errors on credit report.
Eliminate unnecessary endorsements. Ensure you’re not over-insured. Verify dwelling coverage matches current rebuilding cost.
Insurers don’t always volunteer available discounts. Ask specifically about every discount category.

​
What Doesn’t Lower Premiums

Lower home market value doesn’t reduce premiums. Insurance is based on rebuilding cost, not sale price.Land value affects market price but not insurance.
Premium stays the same after mortgage payoff. Risk to insurer is unchanged.You may no longer need to escrow, giving more control over payments.
New paint, landscaping, or decor don’t affect premiums. Only functional improvements (roof, systems) matter.
Homeowners insurance costs have increased significantly in recent years.Contributing factors:
  • Increased natural disaster frequency and severity
  • Rising construction and labor costs
  • Higher reinsurance costs
  • More expensive claims
  • Inflation in materials
  • Legal system abuse in some states
Some states have seen dramatic increases.Highest cost states:
  • Florida (hurricane risk)
  • Louisiana (hurricane, flood)
  • Texas (wind, hail)
  • Oklahoma (tornado, hail)
  • California (wildfire)
Insurers have exited some markets entirely, reducing competition.
  • Shop aggressively in high-cost markets
  • Consider higher deductibles
  • Invest in mitigation (roof, shutters, defensible space)
  • Work with independent agent who represents multiple carriers
  • Consider state-backed insurers of last resort if private market is unavailable

Next: Filing Claims

Process, documentation, and handling disputes

Find Insurance Providers

Research homeowners insurance providers in your area