Skip to main content
Evaluating mortgage lenders means assessing their experience, communication practices, fee structures, and problem-solving abilities before selecting one for a transaction. Lender selection affects more than interest rates. The lender chosen determines pre-approval strength, closing timeline reliability, and how problems are handled during the transaction. Comparing at least three lenders ensures proper evaluation.

​
What to Evaluate

Experience — Lenders closing 10+ loans monthly have exposure to complex scenarios and recognize problems before they escalate. Communication — Real estate transactions require responsiveness outside business hours. Availability during evenings and weekends matters when deadlines are tight. Local knowledge — Relationships with agents, title companies, and appraisers prevent delays and strengthen financing credibility. Problem-solving — When issues arise, experienced lenders have strategies for resolution rather than letting transactions fail. Fee transparency — Costs vary significantly between lenders. Clear breakdowns enable accurate comparison.

​
Essential Questions

“How many loans do you close per month, and how long have you been lending in this market?”Lenders closing 5-10+ loans monthly have exposure to various scenarios. Lower volume may indicate limited experience with complex situations.“What’s your on-time closing rate?”Rates above 95% indicate reliable processes and experienced coordination.“Can you share an example of a difficult deal you closed recently?”Answers reveal problem-solving ability. Inability to provide examples may indicate limited experience.
“Who will be the main point of contact, and how quickly do you typically respond?”Some lenders hand off to processors. Others remain involved throughout. Clarify who handles communication.“Are you available evenings and weekends?”Offer deadlines and urgent requests occur outside business hours. Limited availability creates risk during time-sensitive situations.“How do you keep clients updated throughout the process?”Proactive communication (weekly updates, milestone notifications) prevents surprises. Reactive communication creates uncertainty.
“How many deals have you closed in [target area] in the past year?”Local lenders understand property values, appraisal timelines, and county-specific requirements.“Do you have relationships with local real estate agents and title companies?”Established relationships facilitate communication and can strengthen financing credibility during competitive situations.“Are you familiar with first-time buyer programs or down payment assistance in this area?”Local grants and programs vary by location. Lenders embedded in the market know available options.
“Can you provide a detailed fee breakdown?”Request itemization including origination fee (typically 0.5-1% of loan amount), processing fee, underwriting fee, application fee, and any additional charges.“Which fees are negotiable?”Some lenders reduce or waive fees. Others have fixed pricing. Understanding negotiability provides leverage.“Will you provide a Loan Estimate within 3 days of application?”Required by law. The Loan Estimate shows all costs in writing for accurate comparison.
“What documentation do you need for a real pre-approval?”Proper pre-approvals require W-2s, tax returns, pay stubs, and bank statements upfront. Approvals without documentation are pre-qualifications.“How long does your pre-approval process take?”1-3 business days is standard with complete documentation. Faster timelines may indicate insufficient review.“Do you do a soft or hard credit pull?”Pre-approvals require hard pulls. Multiple hard pulls within 45 days for mortgage shopping count as one inquiry.
“What happens if the appraisal comes in low?”Experienced lenders have strategies: dispute processes, comparable sales research, alternative financing options, or negotiation guidance.“What loan programs do you offer, and how do you help clients choose?”One-size-fits-all recommendations indicate limited analysis. Proper guidance considers down payment, timeline, and financial goals.“Have you ever had a deal fall through? What happened?”Honest answers about failed transactions and lessons learned indicate experience and transparency.

​
Red Flags vs Green Flags

Red Flags — Avoid lenders that:
  • Issue pre-approvals in minutes without documentation
  • Focus only on interest rates, ignoring other factors
  • Provide vague answers about process or experience
  • Show poor responsiveness during initial contact
  • Cannot provide recent client references
Green Flags — Look for lenders that:
  • Ask detailed questions about income, debts, and goals
  • Explain pre-approval process and timeline clearly
  • Provide specific examples of recent transactions
  • Respond within hours, not days
  • Discuss multiple loan options based on individual situations

​
Comparison Process

1

Identify three lenders to interview

Consider local banks, credit unions, and mortgage companies. Ask real estate agents for referrals but evaluate independently.
2

Schedule consultations

Request 20-30 minute calls or meetings. Prepare questions in advance using the list above.
3

Ask identical questions to each

Consistent questions enable direct comparison. Document answers for side-by-side review.
4

Request Loan Estimates for the same scenario

Provide identical information (loan amount, down payment, credit estimate) to each lender. Compare rates, fees, and total costs directly.
5

Evaluate responsiveness

How quickly did they respond to your initial inquiry? Communication patterns during the sales process indicate future service levels.
6

Check reviews and references

Read reviews focusing on communication and closing experience. Request and contact 2-3 recent client references.

​
Comparing Loan Estimates

Loan Estimates are standardized documents that allow direct comparison between lenders. Request estimates based on identical scenarios from each lender to ensure accurate comparison.
  • Interest rate
  • Monthly principal and interest payment
  • Whether rate is locked
  • Total monthly payment including taxes and insurance
  • Mortgage insurance amount and duration
  • Origination charges (lender fees)
  • Services you can shop for (title, survey, pest inspection)
  • Services you cannot shop for (appraisal, credit report)
  • Total closing costs
  • Cash needed to close
  • Total paid over 5 years (includes principal, interest, and mortgage insurance)
  • Annual Percentage Rate (APR) — the true cost including fees
  • Total Interest Percentage (TIP) — total interest as percentage of loan amount
Different assumptions about taxes, insurance, or loan terms make comparison difficult. Ensure each lender uses identical inputs when generating estimates.

​
Beyond the Rate

Interest rate is one factor. Other considerations affect total cost and experience. Closing costs — Lower rates sometimes come with higher fees. Compare total costs over 5 years, not just monthly payment. Lender credits vs points — Lenders may offer credits (reducing closing costs but increasing rate) or charge points (upfront interest reducing rate). Understand how these affect your specific timeline and goals. Service and communication — A slightly higher rate with responsive local service may cost less than a lower rate with poor execution that delays closing. Rate lock terms — How long is the rate locked? What happens if closing is delayed? What does extending a lock cost? On-time closing reliability — Delays cost money. Rate lock extensions, per diem charges, and rescheduling all have costs that can exceed small rate differences.

​
Local vs National Lenders

Local Lenders

  • Relationships with area agents and title companies
  • Understanding of local programs and grants
  • Faster response to market-specific issues
  • Reputation accountability in concentrated markets

National Lenders

  • Competitive rates due to volume
  • Advanced technology platforms
  • Broader loan program options
  • Consistent processes across markets
Neither type is automatically better. Individual loan officer experience, communication style, and local track record matter more than company size or geographic scope.

​
When to Start Research

Begin researching lenders before property shopping. Pre-approval strength affects offer competitiveness. Rushing lender selection after finding a property limits comparison time and negotiating leverage. Early research provides:
  • Time to compare multiple options without pressure
  • Opportunity to verify experience and communication style
  • Ability to address credit or documentation issues before they delay transactions

Pre-Approval

The verification process that protects earnest money

Loan Types

Conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, and other programs

Mortgage Timeline

Process from application through closing

Local vs National Lenders

Trade-offs between local service and national rates

Compare Local Lenders

Research local mortgage lenders with verified reviews, transaction volume, and availability.