Skip to main content
Choosing the right tax professional affects both the accuracy of your returns and the quality of tax planning advice. For real estate matters, experience with property transactions often matters more than credentials alone. Comparing multiple professionals before engaging helps ensure a good fit for your situation.

​
What to Look For

Not all tax professionals have experience with property matters. Look for someone who regularly handles:
  • Rental property taxation
  • Capital gains and exclusions
  • 1031 exchanges
  • Cost basis tracking
  • Depreciation and recapture
  • Passive activity rules
Ask specifically about real estate clients and transaction volume.
Consider credential level appropriate to your needs:
  • CPA: Broadest qualifications, can represent before IRS, handles complex situations
  • Enrolled Agent: Tax specialist, full IRS representation, often lower cost than CPA
  • Tax Preparer: Basic returns only, limited representation
  • Tax Attorney: Legal matters, litigation, criminal issues
For most real estate investors, CPA or EA with property experience is ideal.
Tax questions arise year-round, not just at filing time.
  • Can you reach them outside tax season?
  • Do they offer planning consultations?
  • How quickly do they respond to questions?
  • Will you work with the same person each year?
Find someone who explains things clearly:
  • Answers questions in plain language
  • Proactively identifies issues and opportunities
  • Responds promptly to calls and emails
  • Takes time to understand your situation
Avoid professionals who make you feel rushed or confused.
Modern practices should offer:
  • Secure document upload portal
  • Electronic signature capability
  • Digital copies of returns
  • Organized record retention
Paper-only practices may indicate outdated methods.

​
Questions to Ask

  • How many clients do you have with rental properties?
  • Have you handled 1031 exchanges?
  • Are you familiar with cost segregation studies?
  • What percentage of your practice involves real estate?
  • How long have you been working with property investors?
  • What’s included in your fee for tax preparation?
  • Do you offer tax planning consultations?
  • Will you represent me if I’m audited?
  • How do you stay current on tax law changes?
  • Do you review prior year returns for new clients?
  • What documents will you need from me?
  • What’s your timeline for completing returns?
  • How do you handle questions during the year?
  • What software do you use?
  • How do you handle extensions if needed?
  • How do you charge (flat fee, hourly, per form)?
  • What’s the typical cost for someone in my situation?
  • Are planning consultations billed separately?
  • Do fees increase with additional properties?
  • Is audit representation included or extra?

​
Fee Structures

Fixed price for defined scope of work. Common for straightforward returns.Pros: Predictable cost, no surprise billsCons: May not include additional questions or planningClarify what’s included and what triggers additional fees.
Charges based on number and complexity of forms filed.Pros: Pay for what you need

Cons: Hard to predict total cost in advanceMore forms (rental properties, investments) means higher cost.
Charges based on time spent. Common for planning, complex issues, and representation.Pros: Pay only for actual work

Cons: Unpredictable costs, may hesitate to ask questionsAsk for estimate and request notification if exceeding.
Fee based on complexity and value provided rather than time.Pros: Aligned incentives, includes planning

Cons: May be higher than hourly for simple situationsCommon with firms targeting real estate investors.

​
Typical Costs

ServiceTypical Range
Individual return (simple)$200 - $400
Individual return with rental$400 - $800
Individual return with multiple rentals$600 - $1,200+
Partnership or LLC return$500 - $1,500
Tax planning consultation (hourly)$150 - $400
1031 exchange guidance$500 - $2,000
Audit representation (hourly)$150 - $400
Costs vary by location, complexity, and professional credentials. Higher fees don’t always mean better service.
Request fee estimate in writing before engaging. Clarify what’s included and what would trigger additional charges.

​
Red Flags

No legitimate professional guarantees a refund before reviewing your situation. Refund depends on your facts, not their skill.Promises of specific outcomes suggest aggressive positions or outright fraud.
Charging percentage of refund creates incentive to inflate deductions or credits.IRS prohibits contingent fees for original return preparation. This practice is a major red flag.
Paid preparers must sign returns and include their PTIN. Refusal to sign suggests they don’t stand behind their work.You’re responsible for accuracy regardless of who prepares return.
Good preparers ask questions to understand your situation. Someone who prepares returns without inquiry may miss deductions or make errors.Cookie-cutter approach doesn’t work for real estate situations.
Pushes deductions or positions that seem too good to be true. Aggressive positions create audit risk and potential penalties.Good professionals explain risks and let you decide.
Doesn’t return calls, takes weeks to respond, or disappears after filing season.You need someone available when questions arise, not just at tax time.
You are legally responsible for accuracy of your tax return even if someone else prepares it. Choose professionals carefully and review returns before signing.

​
Interviewing Professionals

Many professionals offer free initial consultation. Use this to assess:
  • Communication style
  • Knowledge of your situation type
  • Interest in your business
  • Office organization and professionalism
Come prepared with overview of your situation and specific questions.
Bring or be ready to discuss:
  • Types of income (W-2, self-employment, rental)
  • Number of properties owned
  • Recent or planned transactions
  • Specific concerns or questions
  • Prior year returns if switching preparers
Interview at least 2-3 professionals before deciding. Compare:
  • Relevant experience
  • Communication quality
  • Fee structure
  • Availability
  • Overall impression
Cheapest option isn’t always best value.

​
When to Switch Professionals

  • Errors on returns requiring amendments
  • Missed deductions or opportunities
  • Poor communication or slow responses
  • Doesn’t understand your situation
  • No proactive planning advice
  • Fees increased significantly without added value
  • Retired or sold practice to someone you don’t know
  • Obtain copies of prior returns (at least 3 years)
  • Get depreciation schedules and basis documentation
  • Request any workpapers or supporting documents
  • Provide new preparer with complete history
Prior preparer must provide copies of your returns. May charge reasonable fee for copies.
Best time to switch is after filing season (May-December). New preparer has time to review history before next filing.Switching mid-season is possible but may be rushed.

​
Building a Long-Term Relationship

Keep preparer informed of changes:
  • Property purchases or sales
  • Major improvements
  • Change in rental status
  • Life changes (marriage, divorce, retirement)
  • Business changes
Surprises at tax time lead to rushed decisions.
Best tax outcomes come from planning, not just filing.
  • Schedule mid-year check-in
  • Discuss major transactions before completing
  • Review estimated tax payments
  • Plan year-end strategies
Make preparer’s job easier:
  • Keep receipts organized by category
  • Track mileage contemporaneously
  • Maintain property files with purchase documents and improvements
  • Provide complete information, not piles of paper
Better records mean more accurate returns and lower fees.

​
DIY vs Professional

  • Simple W-2 income only
  • Primary residence with standard deductions
  • No rental properties
  • Comfortable with tax software
  • Time to research and verify accuracy
Some investors prepare returns themselves but consult professionals for:
  • Annual review of self-prepared return
  • Planning before major transactions
  • Specific questions or complex issues
Can reduce costs while getting professional input on key decisions.
First meeting checklist:
  • Verify credentials (CPA license, EA enrollment, PTIN)
  • Ask about real estate experience
  • Discuss fee structure and get estimate in writing
  • Clarify communication expectations
  • Ask about planning services beyond preparation
  • Request references from real estate clients
  • Trust your instincts about fit and professionalism

Back to Accountants & Tax

Overview of tax professionals and real estate

Find Tax Professionals

Research CPAs and tax professionals with real estate experience